Pining for pies
Traditional versions have nostalgic appeal
Welcome back: Nostalgia and our sweet tooth are nudging some bakers back into the kitchen to give pies a try. Old-fashioned pies especially. (Bill Hogan/Chicago Tribune)
Paula Haney understands this. When the Indiana native opened her Hoosier Mama Pie Shop in Chicago, she made sure that six pies she considers iconic — apple, banana cream, chocolate cream, pecan, cherry and lemon meringue — would be available.
"Those are the biggies that people have emotional feelings about. They taste good, and that's the reason they've survived," says Haney. "But those six pies also tend to be the things that their mothers and grandmothers and great-grandmothers made. Those are ones people love.
"I wanted to make sure we preserved some of these traditional pies," says Haney. "I felt that that whole part of our cooking heritage was being lost."
Yet our appetite for pie doesn't mean everyone took pie-baking lessons from granny. Perhaps that's why there are so many new pie-focused cookbooks with more on the way, including "Pieography: Where Pie Meets Biography," by Jo Packham, with food notables offering pies that capture "the essence" of their lives.
Most aim to erase any fears that pie-baking is difficult or complicated.
"Many folks shy away from pie, thinking it's much too finicky or persnickety for them," Ashley English writes in her book, "A Year of Pies: A Seasonal Tour of Home Baked Pies," (Lark Crafts, $19.95). "I can tell you with the utmost confidence that baking pie is considerably easier than baking many, many other things.
"Creating a delicious pie emboldens you while it satiates you. It lifts you up and gives you hope," English adds. "I know that sounds grandiose (it's only humble pie, after all, right?), but it's true. Crafting and baking a pie is an exercise in patience with a reward in contentment."
"It's like making bread. You can't just follow a recipe and have it turn out. There's a little bit of skill there," says Haney, who has a pie cookbook in the works. "The recipe for the pie crust is going to be variable depending on the weather and humidity, so you kind of have to have a feel for it. Now once you do, then it's really pretty easy. You only have flour, butter and cold water. So I think it takes on this sort of magical thing.
"When people come up with a good pie crust, it's 'How did I turn these three ingredients into something so good?' ... It's just a matter of getting a feel for it and knowing what to look for."
So taste a lot of pie and pie crust, says Haney.
"Pie should just fill up your mouth with flavor. You hit salty and sweet and bitter. ... It should be balanced. The texture shouldn't be gelatinous. It should be kind of silky. And the crust should be good on its own. You should be able to eat a piece of crust and have it taste good."
Thinking of giving pie baking a try? Perhaps an apple (Vermont's state pie) or Key lime (Florida's). Or, this old-fashioned banana cream pie.
Banana cream pie
Prep: 30 minutes
Cook: 15-20 minutes, plus time to bake crust
Chill: 1 hour
Makes: One 9-inch pie, 8 servings
Note: Adapted from "American Cooking," part of Time-Life's Foods of the World series (1968).